GDP Growth by Debt Acceleration
January 7, 2025 by Ednaldo Silva

Consider the reduced-form GDP (behavioral) equation:

(1)      Yt = At + b ΔDt – r Dt-1

where:

a)  Yt is GDP in period t from 1 to T,

b)  At is “autonomous” (Kaleckian) gross accumulation (C + I + X − M),

c)  ΔDt ≡ Dt – Dt-1 is new government debt issuance (debt financing),

d)  b is the fiscal multiplier on debt-financed spending,

e). r Dt-1 are interest payments on the existing debt stock, and

f)  r (viewed as a constant here) is the average interest rate on the government debt.

Equation (1) is basic and applies to any economy, capitalist or socialist, rich or poor.

Taking the one-period (forward) difference, ΔXt ≡ Xt – Xt-1, and noting the second difference Δ2Dt ≡ ΔDt – ΔDt-1, we get:

        ΔYt = ΔAt + b [(Dt – Dt-1) – (Dt-1 – Dt-2)] – r (Dt-1 – Dt-2)

(2)    ΔYt  = ΔAt + b Δ2Dt – r ΔDt-1

Divide both sides of equation (2) by Yt to express the per-period growth rates:

(3)     gt ≡ (ΔYt) / (Yt) = [ΔAt + b Δ2Dt – r ΔDt-1] / (Yt)

where gt = ΔY / Y is the one-period GDP growth rates.

Appendix A: Domar Condition of Debt Sustainability
In his article “Burden of Debt and National Income” (1944), Evsey Domar shows that if we define the debt-to-GDP ratio dt ≡ Dt / Yt, its law of motion (discrete-time analogue) is:

         Δdt = (ΔDt) / (Yt) – dt-1 (ΔYt) / (Yt) = (st + r Dt-1) / (Yt) – gt dt-1

 (4)    Δdt = st / Yt + (r – gt) dt-1,

where st ≡ ΔDt – r Dt-1 is called the primary deficit.

Setting Δdt = 0 for a steady debt-to-GDP ratio gives:

d* = (s / Y) / (g – r),

which is finite (and positive) only if g > r.

Conversely, if g < r then Δd > 0 and the debt/GDP ratio explodes. Hence the growth rate of GDP must exceed the interest rate for public debt to be sustainable.

Appendix B: Recasting Equation (3) as a Domar-Style Inequality
From equation (3), debt sustainability (g > r) becomes:

(5)     (ΔAt + b Δ2Dt – r ΔDt-1)/(Yt) > r ==> ΔAt + b Δ2Dt > r (Yt + ΔDt-1).

To obtain a growth rate above the borrowing rate r, the net injection of autonomous demand growth (ΔA) plus the acceleration of debt-financed spending (b Δ2D) must cover the interest drain on past debt: r ΔDt-1.

In summary, Domar’s condition is about nominal GDP growth vs. nominal interest rates;

Domar (1944) shows that if:

dt = (Dt) / (Yt)

is the debt‐to‐GDP ratio, its approximate law of motion is:

(7)     Δdt ≈ (rnominal – gnominal) dt-1 + (primary deficitt) / (Yt).

In steady state (no change in d), we need to satisfy:

gnominal > rnominal

to prevent Δdt > 0 from becoming uncontrolled by monetary or fiscal policy..

References

Evsey Domar, “The ‘Burden of the Debt’ and the National Income,” American Economic Review (December 1944): https://www.jstor.org/stable/1807397

Gross accumulation is a concept from Michał Kalecki, Theory of Economic Dynamics (2nd edition), George Allen & Unwin, 1965.